Skip to content
Sign In Subscribe
 

Street pedlars quitting, e-bikes still roaming free. Is the Briggate action plan working?

Briggate is changing. The pedlars have lost their lucrative spot and the bikes are next. Original illustration by Jake Greenhalgh

'Coincidentally all of these frowned upon things are suddenly available on Park Row, The Headrow, King Edward St and others.'

“This is our line”. Crêpe seller Hewadmal Quraishe looks down, pointing out where the pattern in the street flooring changes. The double row of corrugated slabs his trolley sits on were presumably first put in as a guide to the blind. Now, they act as a hard border, cutting him out from the riches of Briggate.

We’re just off to the side of Leeds’ main thoroughfare, outside Tesco on The Headrow. Hewadmal is one of many “pedlars” who have had to adapt following the introduction of the council’s Briggate Action Plan, which came into force on October 1.

Pedlars — mobile businesses without a fixed pitch — were banned from Briggate and several connecting streets (George Street, Kirkgate, Lands Lane, Albion Place, Commercial Street, Bond Street and a large part of Albion Street) as well as in and around Leeds Arena and Millenium Square. The rules came with a new Public Space Protection Order (PSPO) to enforce them.

A map showing the prohibited areas: blue is all-year round and the red pinstriped area is for selected events. Image: Leeds City Council

A council spokesperson said: “The aim is to take important and meaningful steps to address issues which the public have consistently told us were impacting their enjoyment of the city centre whilst also creating potential safety issues for shoppers and pedestrians”. Many of the pedlars would congregate in the same area at the same time, according to the council, which caused access issues, as well as “associated anti-social behaviour and the sale of counterfeit goods”.

But it’s left Leeds’ trolley traders with a problem. Move from their most lucrative spot (the crossroads with Kirkgate and Commercial Street) or risk a £100 Penalty Charge Notice or worse, prosecution with a maximum fine of up to £1,000.

When I visit Briggate on Tuesday, shoppers are bustling around, lured out of the biting cold into warm, festive shops. But the phone-accessory sellers, crêpe makers and sweetcorn shakers are nowhere to be seen. 

That’s not to say you can’t buy any food on the street – a worker in the Falafel Guys caravan busily leaps back and forth as he serves customers, while the Korean Food Station is still present. But the council tells me these are street traders, which are different to pedlars, and they have a fixed pitch that’s licensed through the local authority.

I do spot one man pushing a cart: the fabled “chestnut man”. He’s still there, his sales pitch (“Hot chestnuts, get your hot chestnuts”) ringing out across Briggate as it has since 1926, according to the sign on his trolley. I approach him for a chat, but he tells me he’s too busy trying to sell to speak. My offer of speaking over the phone at a better time is rejected.

Still, it seems that chestnut man (I never did get his name) falls into yet a third category: he has booked a trading pitch with the council’s markets team. This is a temporary licence due to the seasonal nature of his product.

The street traders with licences that are able to trade on Briggate and other prohibited zones.

“Briggate Action Plan - Success!”

A few days after the introduction of the PSPO, a post appeared on the dedicated Leeds subreddit titled: “Briggate Action Plan - Success!” It was satirical, including a picture of a pedlar on Park Row and The Headrow. “Great news! As promised Briggate has been cleaned up… no more traders with trolleys, no more sweetcorn, street soup, churros or crepes. Coincidentally all of these frowned upon things are suddenly available on Park Row, The Headrow, King Edward St and others.” Others joined in the criticism. “So instead of just avoiding Briggate to avoid all of this, people have got to dodge it everywhere else. What a stroke of genius,” wrote one. 

The satirical Reddit post. Image: Reddit

Is that actually true though? Are the pedlars simply moving their business?

Hewadmal, the crêpe seller, is almost startled when I first approach him just before 5.30pm, then excited at the prospect of me being just his second customer of the day (he started at 3pm). There was a lot of business for the pedlars down on Briggate, but in their new home, he says “it’s too much quiet for us”. “Every pedlar is struggling with this business, some come on the weekend, not every day. If [it continues] like this, I’m [going to] leave this business.” Vijay Bajhel of Falafel Guys, who is close with some of the pedlars, sympathises with their plight. “They’re struggling”, he says, adding that his friends are only making £20 a day sometimes, when they could take £100-£150 on a good day before. “They should be allowed, because it’s not fair for them, everyone has to pay bills.”

Quitting would be tricky for Hewadmal: he has a family to provide for. An Afghan national, he worked with the British Forces prior to moving over before the 2021 evacuation, he tells me. He is trying to build a comfortable life for his family here and two days a week he attends the Printworks Campus of Leeds City College to study as a vehicle technician. That will take a few years, though, and he has to get by until then. When a rare customer hovers nearby, I see a yearning in Hewadmal’s face, anxious that the opportunity doesn’t pass him by. I leave him to earn his livelihood.

Crêpe seller Hewadmal Quraishe looks longingly for a customer. Image: Brad Deas/The Exchange

Just over the road is sweetcorn seller, Khir Mohammed. Also an Afghan, Khir has built up quite a reputation. “I have a regular 80 customers”, he tells me, something he told the council in an attempt to remain. It’s a far cry from the days when he was a British interpreter with the special forces before being made redundant in 2015 and moving over to Britain, but this is what Khir knows now. “The opportunity for a different way, they [the council] didn’t give. They moved [us] from the trading area. Most people have left this job, some like us [have been here] for 11 years”, he says.

Both men say they are willing to abide by any rules that could be set to allow them to continue trading on Briggate and would happily pay rent for a fixed spot. A spokesperson for the council tells me mobile pedlars are not able to apply for a licence through the local authority, which is the key to being able to trade within the prohibited areas. In theory, a pedlar could express interest in becoming a licensed street trader but would need to operate their trolley from a designated pitch, the spokesperson tells us.

Two pedlars on The Headrow. Image: Brad Deas/The Exchange

Khir tells me he spoke to the public and businesses on Briggate and claims: “they say, 'we don’t have any problems with traders'”. A worker in Flannels who I speak to when visiting Briggate on Thursday agrees. “They’re not really a problem, they always seemed quite busy. A lot of the Chinese and Asian community liked the sweetcorn”, she says.

But Elaine Kennedy, who is with her friend Margaret Hastings shopping in Leeds on Thursday, says, “It looks better. There should be certain places, not the main part, it’s not good for the big [stores]”. As for Rebecca Hynes from Huddersfield, she confesses to having an affinity for the sweetcorn, though isn’t a fan of the “phone tat” and certainly not the street preachers, who she says are “so aggressive”. “Freedom of speech is one thing, but freedom of yelling is a bit much.”

A two-wheel problem

Then there’s the other bugbear of so many on Briggate: e-bikes. Under the new plan, cyclists must walk (rather than ride) within the city centre’s pedestrianised shopping area from 10.30am until 8pm every day. The council says: “An estimated 1,100 bikes travel up and down Briggate each day, including heavy bikes used by delivery drivers, which can travel up to 45mph and pose a serious potential risk to pedestrian safety.”

While I’m there, I see at least a dozen bikes, the majority of them hefty e-bikes, one whizzing just inches away from me. I assume the rules are just being flouted, but a council spokesperson said the regulations have actually yet to come into effect. A separate traffic regulation order is required, they say, which has a statutory period between when it’s advertised and when it can be brought in. This, alongside a separate PSPO, will come into force “later this year”. 

One of a dozen e-bike riders I saw heading down Briggate one evening. Image: Brad Deas/The Exchange

It can’t come soon enough for Margaret and Elaine. Margaret tells me they’ve nearly been knocked over multiple times. “They’re not bothered”, she adds. “It’s frightening, they don’t slow down”, Elaine adds.

It remains to be seen whether the PSPO can stop this — after all, it’s easier to enforce rules against static trolleys than bikes going 45mph. For the pedlars, at least, in the six weeks since the PSPO came into force 105 people have been asked to leave the banned zones, and 32 have been issued with £100 fines. There have not yet been attempted prosecutions. The council spokesperson says: “During the initial period, enforcement has been carried out proportionately, with a focus on education and awareness.”

The hope is that day-to-day visits to the city centre and major events will now be “even more enjoyable, successful and welcoming”. Maybe, but that success seemingly doesn't stretch to the pedlars. On Thursday, as the evening draws in, I wander to the top of Briggate. Khir is there, but Hewadmal is nowhere to be seen.

Our journalism is different, because our model is different. We're funded almost entirely by members, which means we're answerable to you, not faceless tech companies. If you think Leeds needs that, then join us. It's cheaper than Amazon Prime or Spotify, and much, much better for the place where you live.

Join up

Think this adds to the conversation? Or provides some insight you think other people should know about? Please do share this around, it helps us massively.

Share

Comments

Latest